Belvedere CA Real Estate Review Dec. 2011

December 12, 2011

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 6:48 am

Chart Guide: The below charts include a great deal of data. Besides the two charts immediately below titled “Marin Real Estate Pullbacks” & “Southern Marin Price Index”, all charts show annual data, business cycle average and trailing 12 month stats. The business cycle average can be considered a  ”Intrinsic Value” estimate. The years where the county or town was trading above the business cycle average relates to market conditions dominated by optimism/exuberance and the years where it trades under this business cycle average is more dominated by fear/pessimism/uncertainty & restraint. The trailing 12 month data column will eventually meet with 2011 data column and is a barometer of which direction the market is heading. If the trailing 12 month number is higher than the 2011 number, it means market conditions were generally better at the end of 2010 then they are today.

Marin Real Estate Pullbacks– shows the severity of the recent real estate downturn, for perspective. There have only been two years since county-wide average data started being compiled where Marin County-wide Real Estate prices declined year on year– after the S&L crisis in 91-92 where Marin County prices decreased a little over 1% each year. Against this back drop of generally stable upward-sloping prices the Great Recession obliterated this trend with large price drops:

Mile High: Southern Marin County Price Index is a town-weighted-average by unit sales. TiburonBelvedere RESI prices (condo & SFR) are having very difficult years (both off -20%) as the high end of the market is still very slow and is dragging this SOMA index to the lowest point in the trailing business cycle (about 7 years).

The below 2 charts show Belvedere CA Property prices. the first is median price and the second is TDG Price index which is a mixture of average prices, median prices and is a function of the size of the house. Belvedere real estate average SFR prices are off  -18% and median prices are off about -10%. This is one of the worst years on record for Belvedere.

The TDG index is down 11% which is a closer to telling the full story than the -14% SFR average price decline is due to the lack of high end sales. There have only been 2 homes that have traded so far in 2011 above $4m (thru Dec. 1st), as opposed to 6 in each of the other years of the recession (2008-2011).

Interestingly– lot values have actually increased in 2011. The second chart below shows that the amount people are paying for the actual structure of the house has decreased about 4%. Please compare these charts together thru the years of the great recession. Lots values have fallen 23% from the peak, whereas prices are off 30% from the peak. This means buyers still pay up to live in Belvedere, but they are buying smaller homes at lower price points. However, note that the selling $/sqft of the actually house without the lot has increased in 2011– see second chart down:

The most misunderstood market statistic is the below chart selling: $/sqft. Buyers should never try to compare homes by this barometer especially in locations where architecture and lot/locations vary greatly as they do in Marin County. The greatest repository of home value is lot/location which is not explained well by selling $/sqft of the house. It is an interesting statistic for market-wide analysis- and by this metric Belvedere CA Real Estate is down 7% in 2011.

Earning Your Business

The purpose of this Southern Marin Real Estate Blog is to offer greater insight into our local real estate markets than you can find anywhere else– to help you make better decisions for yourselves and your family. The research found in these pages is my competitive advantage in this market. I have yet to find a rational buyer who doesn’t respond to this data; remember most buyers emotionally want to buy a house– they just don’t understand the value proposition. You deserve a agent to represent you on either side of the transaction that has done  their homework.  If you are thinking about listing or buying a home all I ask is that you include me in your interviewing process.

Thank you & Happy Holidays!

Dave DuPont MBA, CFP


Belvedere CA Real Estate Data Q2 2011

July 3, 2011

Filed under: 2. Southern Marin,Belvedere — dwdupont @ 11:34 am

Please scoll down to see Q2 2011 Data. Also please consider that I compile all this data personally. Your choice to work with us will save you money as the incredible time commitment required to assemble and publish this data each quarter results in much stronger and more dynamic negotiations which ultimately benefit you whether you’re a buyer or a seller:

Big Picture:
A distinct surge in positive home buying sentiment appeared in the first few months of 2011 triggered primarily by people wanting the recession to be done with and reacting to each positive media announcement as proof that the “Great Recession” was FINALLY OVER!  Unfortunately, the earthquake and tsunami in Japan, and the revolutions in the Middle East combined with dismal US economic data domestically reversed this media consumer trend and scared the home buying turtles back in their shells.

The current statistics clearly indicated a double dip in prices in Marin County—the severity of which is town dependent: Tiburon is having its worst year on record while Ross, and Kentfield are having quite positive years. This broad based double dip in prices is more reflective of sellers finally accepting the new pricing structure that a general decline in the pricing structure itself.

This double dip in prices combined with rising (energy) prices hint to a potential rough economy for a year or two ahead. I anticipate 5 more years of  challenging real estate market conditions broken up by brief periods of buying activity.

Seller Tips:

  • Sellers need to be priced properly, on the MLS, and on lockbox available for buyers to see at a moment’s notice to capture these fleeting spikes of buyer activity.
  • The market has never been more price dependent and buyers never more informed and  price conscious. Homes must be priced within a “window of perceived value” in order to garner offers—otherwise the property won’t get many showings and is quite unlikely to sell.
  • The typical seasonal trends of strong Springs and slow Summers & New Years have changed and now any time of the year is an equally challenging time list your home for sale. We never know when these spikes of buyer activity will occur and during the Great Recession they have occured sporadically year yound.

Buyer Tips:

  • Success for home buyers is dependent on a quick trigger finger. Homes sit until prices fall into the window of perceived vale and then they sell very quickly. Don’t lose the deal because of a rounding error in highly charge negotiations.
  • Buyers need to price homes by lot value and structure cost in addition to “the comps”. I have recently seen some homes trade for too much and others not enough because of valuation uncertainty.

Belvedere CA Real Estate & Belvedere CA Homes

Statistically, Belvedere is having another terrible year. The pricing structure for the town was reset lower by the financial crisis & recession and sellers have yet to adjust. Buyer preferences currently favor flat yards, a pool, and warmer summer days, leading them north to preferential neighborhoods in Ross, Kentfield and Larkspur.

Homes need to be properly priced and positioned to capture fleeting moments of buying activity. This can take a few hours or 3 months. The idea of pricing a home high in the hopes of “finding the right buyer” no longer pertains to the current market. Very few homes have sold in the high end, due mostly to pricing.

In an average year during the last business cycle 31 homes change hands at about $3 million. The trailing 12 months show 33 homes have sold at a price 6% below the business cycle mean and 10% below by $/SQFT; average days on market is 185!

As you scan the data below please consider that we compile all this data personally. We don’t buy it and paste it here. Your choice to work with us will save you money as the incredible time commitment required to assemble and publish this data each quarter results in much stronger and more dynamic negotiations which ultimately benefit you whether you’re a buyer or a seller.

The DuPont Group is a dynamic real estate team active in Southern and Central Marin communities. Dave received his MBA from Pepperdine University and is a Certified Financial Planner (CFP). Please call or email us anytime for more information


Belvedere CA Real Estate Q1 2011 Update

April 13, 2011

Filed under: 2. Southern Marin,Belvedere — dwdupont @ 12:46 pm

Belvedere CA Real Estate Trends

Belvedere 2010 was the busiest year since 2005 by unit sales, but like other S. Marin towns prices are still falling and have reached new post recession lows in Q1 ’11. Belvedere real estate is a tale of two markets: wonderful homes in preferential locations continue to sell at premium prices as the 12/23/10 sale of 67 Belvedere exemplifies.

In an average year during the last business cycle  30 homes sold in Belvedere at an average price of $3.2m or $992.sqft. The trailing 12 months topped this pace in unit sales, but at 7% lower prices. The biggest hit to Belvedere real estate are lot values—off almost 18%.

Of all Southern Marin County towns Belvedere has the fewest homes in contract. At 18% Belvedere is still stuck in a difinitive buyers market. o% of the homes in the top quartile of listings are in contract. Interestingly when compaing the lot value and structure value charts at the bottom you see that buyers are looking for finished homes and not so much looking for a project on a great lot. In fact– the depreciated structure value of homes that have traded in the last 12 months is very near the business cycle average, which is strong. Unfortunately, lot values are off -18% right now– with the cost of  building on the island combined with the near lunacy at the planning board, one can understand buyers reluctance to embrace a property that needs a makeover.

All towns in Southern Marin react to business cycle changes differently. Belvedere usually leads the market as generally the folks who have made it onto the island are there for a reason (i.e. they don’t waste time writing real estate blogs that no one reads)– Belvedere home owners understand the phases of the business cycle and can postion themselves for the upcycle. It is interesting that there is so little activity happening on the island one must consider that pricing could be a factor… why:

 The commercial real estate market for office space in San Francisco has come alive and is a prelude to increased demand in Marin County in 6-12 months. We went to a panel of commercial real estate entrepreneurs in San Francisco 3/30/11 including Maxwell Drever, Doug Shorenstein, and Stuart Shiff and they are all positioned for liquidating in the next ‘up’ market– i.e. they know the cycle has turned and are ahead of the curve. Their message about the market for commercial opportunities was : if you are waiting for “the bottom” it has already passed. The “generational opportunities” you heard about in the press were few and far between. There is a mountain of global money chasing cash flow from the best buildings in the best locations in the US—and these are trading at attractive prices. Older assets and those in sub-par locations simply aren’t trading or are going very cheap.

 There are a number of incredible properties listed for sale but at eye-popping prices. The truth is that it can cost thousands of dollars a square foot to build in these dramatic Belvedere locations– one seller claims to have over $3500/sqft invested in their home.

As you scan the data below please consider that we compile all this data personally. We don’t buy it and paste it here. Your choice to work with us will save you money as the incredible time commitment required to assemble and publish this data each quarter results in much stronger and more dynamic negotiations which ultimately benefit you whether you’re a buyer or a seller.

This is the “recovery” we are talking about is all about liquidity– sellers able to find buyers. Many parts of the county do not have this kind of liquidity and the result is that 1 in 24 homes are in foreclosure and in many areas like Reno, Sacramento, Boise and many small cities in Florida the number is 1 in 10 homes in foreclosure.  When you measure Southern Marin County Real Estate in relation to these other areas what you see is a recovering market here and that is confirmed by commercial real estate movements in San Francisco forcasting new jobs and increased demand on the horizon.

Belvedere CA Real Estate, like Tibruon and Mill Valley has just hit a new recession price low.

The TDG Price index below is a combination of median prices, average prices, $/sqft and home size ans is more telling than either average or median prices alone. By this measure the trailing 12 month data is slightly better than 2010 data which actually is good as the winter is always slow with weaker demand/prices, and the trailing 12 months data at the end of Q1 includes 2 winter periods. I think prices this Spring with bounce given the liquidity in the market, the activity in SF resi, and commercial real estate activity in SF.

The DuPont Group is a dynamic real estate team active in Southern and Central Marin communities. Dave DuPont received his MBA from Pepperdine University and is a Certified Financial Planner (CFP). Please call or email us any time for more information. We are eager to earn your business.


Belvedere CA Real Estate – Q4 & 2010 Market Data

December 15, 2010

Filed under: 2. Southern Marin,Belvedere — dwdupont @ 4:07 pm

Belvedere Q4 Update & Yearly Real Estate Review

Its been a difficult year for most properties priced above $1.5m. Recently there has been tremendous improvement in most market segments except the high end Belvedere CA Real Estate. In fact, the most notable story in S. Marin real estate is the continuing price slide in Belvedere—currently tied with Novato for the biggest price drop from the peak. Belvedere average prices are down ~29% from the 2007 high.

In thinly traded towns like Belvedere Homes, which averages just 29 sales each year, missing even several high end sales can mean the difference between a flat year and a statistically poor year– which is exactly what is happening this year.

There are 31 homes currently for sale in Belevedere; the average listing price is $6,775,097 or $1,427/sqft– the implied average lot value of these listings is above $5.3m. The average lot value in Belvedere is actually closer to $1.54m which means the lot / land component of value (as opposed to the actual structure / house value) of the average listing in Belvedere is 350% over priced.

Please call for more information and visit our property website at www.thedupontgroup.net .

Last, we spend a great deal of time researching these statistics. It is our competitive edge in the marketplace for your benefit– as we very often use this data to support our price negotiations. We work harder than other agents on this data primarily because want to earn your business. Please call or email us us today. 415-867-6611 Dave@thedupontgroup.net .

Happy Holidays & New Year!


Q3 Belvedere CA Real Estate Review

October 5, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 11:55 am

 


Belvedere CA Real Estate: Fall 2010 Update

August 21, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 9:48 am

Statistically, Belvedere home prices have really taken a fall since my last update. Average prices are down another -17% from 2009 levels and over -40% from the top. The only segment of the market that has had any traction at all this year is the bottom half of the market as the sales below show: there have only been 3 sales in the middle market and none in the high end.

5 N Point Cir  1,550,000 2939 527 256
1 Hilarita Cir  1,725,000 2675 645 320
49 Bellevue Ave  1,750,000 1342 1304 32
19 Acacia Ave  1,963,000 2700 727 38
11 Britton Ave  2,250,000 3647 617 518
412 Golden Gate Ave  2,295,000 2867 800 23
19 Belvedere Ave  2,300,000 2407 956 132
430 Bella Vista Ave  2,300,000 2889 796 102
29 Peninsula Rd  2,350,000 1412 1664 28
213 Golden Gate Ave  2,423,000 3183 761 35
83 W Shore Rd -2461 2,500,000 3481 718 234
14 Laurel Ave  2,625,000 4100 640 22
7 Edgewater Rd  3,300,000 3085 1070 28
180 San Rafael Ave  4,000,000 4112 973 210
3 Britton Ave  4,580,000 4280 1070 80
Average 2,527,400 3,008 885 137

Our office has two $7m deals near closing. The issue is not desirability of Belvedere homes—the issue is pricing. The average listing price is $6,130,000 or $1,365/sqft. This implies an average lot value of $4.3m for the town of Belvedere—well above my research which shows the average lot value in Belvedere is worth ~$1.9m. Please reference below average lot value graphs.

The truth is there are a quite a selection of high end and wonderful properties on the market, but almost every one is priced for a very stong economic recovery.

Please reference our main website www.thedupontgroup.net or call Dave 415-867-6611 for more information.


Belvedere Real Estate Update

May 20, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 9:47 am

Belvedere homes and home prices are similar to Tiburon (or vice versa). Troubled Belvedere homeowners as well as sellers that simply want to move for ANY reason, have been holding out for 20 months now. But they can’t hold out forever; and we are now finally seeing homes trade at more reasonable prices.

Like every town in the county, loans were taken for a variety of reasons (remodel, vacation, new cars etc) leveraging real estate like it was a Treasury Bond with a guaranteed return. The middle chapters of this story are now complete: these real estate return assumptions were faulty, but the money was already spent (growing our economy at an unsustainable GDP rate). And now after years and years of living in Belvedere, as well as months (or years) spent on remodel with very high input costs (wages & materials), these homes that are finally coming to the market are priced to “get their investment out”. Homes priced this way rarely sell in a declining market where other comparable homes nearby are “priced to sell”.

There are $200,000,000 worth of homes for sale on and off the MLS in Belvedere alone. The longer these homes site on the market, the lower they will sell for. The average list price of a home in Belvedere is $5,000,000.

We have entered a period of much slower growth due primarily to 2 things: the demographic reality of the baby boomer generation on the down slope of its generational spending cycle, and second—a glut of debt on every level: consumer, municipality, state, region and nation.

Homes sold for very high prices in 2005-2007 during the peak spending years of the baby boomers and the peaking lending years by banks. There may be a few homes purchased by buyers at prices where money is less important than finding the perfect house; but most of these homes will likely sell at lower prices. The longer sellers wait to drop their prices the less they will get for their homes.


Belvedere CA Real Estate Update

April 30, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 6:43 am

4/22/10:  The trend is slightly improving here in Belvedere. There are 2 more homes on the market than there was 30 days ago AND 2% more of the homes on the market are incontract.

There are two schools of thought regarding which end of the real estate market leads the area out of weakness. On the one hand– the ultra high end of the market is represented by the ultra successful which have proven their hand in the market place. Some people believe that this market segment leads the area of weakness.

I however, believe that generally the lower end of the market leads the area– that liquidity in the lower end enables home owners to trade up as their incomes and families increase; that this demand trickles its way upmarket until it reaches the higher end. This is what is happening now– as the liquidity in the lower market segments over the last 4+ months is just now reaching upmarket.

To a certain extent both are true depending on the economic circustances (job market) and what is happening with the stock & capital markets.

This site works in conjuctuion with www.thedupontgroup.net our primary website and if you have any questions please do not hesitate to call me 415-867-6611.


Belvedere Q1 Market Update

April 2, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 11:47 am

The Spring 2010 market is off to a roaring start. The momentum started late in 2009 in the lower market segments (bottom 2 price quartiles of each town) and has continued in those market segments. The health of any real estate market originates in the lower market segments and slowly ripples up the price spectrum until at the end of the cycle the top of the market peaks when the lower end has already started contracting—as happened in the last cycle. While average, median & $/SQFT price trends are marginally improving, unit sales are seeing a greater bounce.

Please start by reading the Marin Update:  at right click “Marin Update”.

Additional information regarding Belvedere CA Real Estate can be found on www.TheDuPontGroup.net , our groups primary website.


Belvedere CA Real Estate 2009 Review

February 11, 2010

Filed under: Belvedere — dwdupont @ 9:41 pm

Marin County Update
In the last 44 years, there have been only two years (excluding 2008 & 2009) when average home prices in Marin County have decreased from one year to the next: -1.2% in 1991 and -1.4% in 1992– after the S&L crisis.

Marin County average residential home prices fell -12.7% in 2008 and -21% in 2009.  

 A unit-sale weighted average of Southern, Central & Northern Marin show Southern Marin prices are down -17.4%, Central Marin down -13.1%, and Northern Marin down -18.4% from 2008 levels.

For much more more information from a mile high perspective please see right nav bar, click & read “Marin Update”.

Belvedere Real Estate
Belvedere current market conditions mimic the larger trend in Marin County– the lower part of the market is very active and the high end is really slow.

Statistically Belvedere home prices, like Tiburon home prices, have shown remarkable resilience so far. However– there are a number of homes in Belvedere on the market that have been sitting for over a year at what I consider to be very attractive prices and still haven’t sold. Several homes come immediately to mind. The truth is that the wealthier a town is the longer home owners can hold out during periods of dropping prices. But they can’t hold out forever. There are about 10 homes currently on the market in Belvedere at pretty much ludicrous prices. Sellers in Belvedere who are reading this blog are encouraged to read the Marin Update blog and to Google “T2 Housing Report” or call me and I will email the report to you. If you need or want to sell your house in the next 5 years I would suggest being very aggressive with pricing now to capture the demand that is clearly present.

The low end of Belvedere real estate is very strong right now with all the homes in the bottom quartile that are on the market currently in contract. The middle market and upper end is still very slow.  Also– notice that over 50% of the homes on the market are clustered in the top pricing quartile– while this part of the market has been quite slow for a while and inventory has backed up in this market segment– it is also historically a characteristic of mispricing relative to exisitng demand:

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Inventory Graph

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Belvedere Inventory Graph 2

There are a few homes that have sold at remarkably low prices in 2010, but most of the homes that were for sale and didn’t sell are either off the market temporarily are in the process of refinance.

Several brokers who have been in the business for a while anticipate that 2010 we will see more foreclosures in Marin than we did in 2009; wealthier people can simply hold out longer.

4th Quarter comparisons

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Quarterly Housing Data

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Quarterly Housing Data 2

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Quarterly Housing Data 3

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Quarterly Housing Data

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Quarterly Housing Data 4 

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Annual Price Trends

Notice the rates of return above and below when you add the effects of leverage (mortgage). Why would you invest your money in anything else? During the early Bubble years I worked at Merrill Lynch as CFP/Financial planner/advisor and everyone i spoke with in the Bay Area was investing in real estate. Young professionals were taking $50,000 bonus’ and leveraging up into $2mm investment properties. I tried to tell everyone we were approaching the end of the cycle and that prices were bound to correct. Unfortunately– there was no data to draw from that showed that real estate prices could actually go down… so everybody assumed it was a risk free investment; and by comparison stocks, bonds and mutual funds looked relatively boring with low returns.

Belvedere Ca Real Estate Investment Return  

Belvedere CA Real Estate Annaul Housing Data

Belvedere CA Real Estate Annaul Housing Data 2 

The average home buyer in Belvedere needs almost $1,000,000 cash in the bank to afford a downpayment on an average home with a 70% mortgage, while also retaining a rainy day fund of cash left over in the bank should anything go wrong.

Belvedere CA Real Estate Census & income data

The town of Belvedere has about 890 homes and just over 2,000 residents and surprisingly few kids.

Belvedere CA Real Estate Census & income data 2

In 2008 and 2009, Dave and the DuPont Group are leading agents in Marin County Real Estate. Since the recession began in earnest in 2008, Dave personally closed over 36 sales and $47m in real estate sales, and his group has closed over $60m. For 2 years running Dave has sold more homes than any other agent at DB Sotheby’s Intl Realty. The data in these pages represents the extra mile we go for clients and is our competitive advantage over other agents in all parts of Marin. Now is not the time to select an agent to represent you because they are a friend or even because they may have represented you in the past. The work habits most realtors has evolved over the past 20 years are not translating well into selling homes in today’s real estate environment where home buyers make decisions because of financial considerations as opposed to emotional ones.

Dave is a Certified Financial Planner (CFP), Certified Financial Manager (CFM), received his MBA from Pepperdine University, a CA real estate broker and worked for approximately 10 years in the San Francisco financial district. This Blog works in conjunction with The DuPont Groups primary web site.

Please call me to discuss this information in more detail 415-867-6611 – Dave


Powered by WordPress